|
Posted By :
akk_ar48@rediffmail.com
|
|
Date :
5/28/2009 3:04:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian beats can move us but feelings can take us away into a world of imagination |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ravij_rawat@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
4/14/2009 11:51:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
poiuytrewq |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ravij_rawat@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
4/12/2009 5:31:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
western classical |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
neel.phukan@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
4/16/2009 5:36:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian for its great classical music history and even the western people also agree it. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
tonybedi@ibibo.com
|
|
Date :
4/18/2009 11:05:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian music is best |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
hyper3@hypersoftsolutions.com
|
|
Date :
4/28/2009 11:46:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Which form of classical music is more powerful, Western or Indian |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
nishqx@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
7/4/2009 3:00:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian def... its indian classical music that has given origin to the word 'classical music'.. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
pradeepattrimonty@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
7/6/2009 3:30:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Your Answer.... |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
diljeet.singh@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
8/2/2009 11:52:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian classical music is more powerful because it is more complicated, melodious, and difficult to perform than compared to western classical music. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
coolkamal89@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
8/31/2009 12:41:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
It doesn't matter who's the best. It matters how they touch other's life. Same is with Music. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
anirudh.ka@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
9/2/2009 2:53:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
could i have address of all locations in delhi |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
seriousstone89@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
5/15/2009 11:21:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
It depends on you. Whichever between the two makes you feel the music is powerful to you. I understand Western Culture more than Indian. Thats why to me Western is more powerful. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ankit05.s@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
5/30/2009 4:26:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian classical music of course! coz western music seems to have come out of it, coz a tabla that have been played here long before Akbar! seem to have same beat sense as the jazz music! 16 and 16! |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
Fred_eminor@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
6/10/2009 1:38:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Western Classical is the most powerful because it has unlimited techniques, dynamics, flares, articulations. and it has alot of dynamics which is unlimiter and unlimited scales unlike indian has specified scales, but in western even in one scale alot of interpretition can be altered which gives us a wide rangne in playing and singing and playing, and also we can use alot of our imagination which is fun, exciting, and challenging |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
jawadmahsud@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
9/20/2009 11:35:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
i think indian clasical music is powerful,because it touches hearts.(im from pakistan)and i love indian music. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
mohit_it743@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
10/2/2009 2:48:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
THE BEST FORM OF MUSIC IS CLASSICAL AS IT RELATES US TO OUR CULTURE,OUR SOUL AND TEACHES US THE BASIS OF SINGING TOO. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
stalwartsandeep@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
4/22/2009 11:58:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Though Indian music is essentially monophonic while Western music can be polyphonic, monophonic or a combination of both; I still feel Indian classical music is more powerful.
Western classical music is based upon the equal tempered scale, and rests upon melody, harmony and counterpart while Swara and Tala are the two basic components of Indian classical music.
Swaras are the twelve notes and the intervening semitones , while a Tala is a cycle of beats, starting with a stress point called the Sam and ending with a release point called the Khali. It is this (sam & khali) that brings life to a Tala.
I feel Indian Clasical Music is more powerful because the roots of this is relegious and how can we ignore the most important factor i.e, Guru-Shishya relationship. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ashir.ailawadi@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
5/16/2009 2:46:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I think western classical is more powerful coz of following reasons :
1. As far as vocals is concerned Indian classical concentrates on the efficient use of notes, melody, rythm and 'Sur' but no emphasis is given to the vocal
production where as in case of western classical, apart frm the above mentioned things, you also learn different techniques of vocal production and delivery,
how to project your voice so that it is full of depth and power, different areas to resonate your voice so that each time your voice has a different effect,
to use your whole body to support your singing rather than depending entirely on ur vocal chords, using your voice to ur full xtent (covering all the
registers), etc.
2. Western classical is far more structured and organised than indian classical. You just give a printred sheet f staff notations and any musician having a
knowledge of western classical can use it on any instrument....Notations are the same for all the insrtuments.....
3. In indian classical music your domain is very constricted as in its really very difficult to switch between various 'Ragas' and thus people usually dont
do this whereas western classical is very flexible and thus gives you a wide space for experimentation.....
4. Western classical delas with things like harmony, symphony, etc very efficiently..
5. Last but not the least, when you talk about the impact on the listener,a layman always interprets music as how gud it FEELS to listen to it and he dsnt
bother about all the technical stuff....and its really difficult for everyone to understand indian classical for the 'FEEL' associated with it can be
understood nly by a few who have themselves learnt it or atleast have an idea f it.... |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
raahul.jain@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
6/1/2009 10:40:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian classical music is more powerful and strong as it has made western change their music moulding into ours !! |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
indu_online_18@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
6/18/2009 12:00:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian classical music is more powerful because it consists of our very old heritage. our classical music is is also based on our lord such as lord krishna etc. and in our ancient times classical music made history by burning the candles, coming of rain, etc.. and on other hand it can also helps people suffering from pain, tension and depresion. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
nitin.sharma@sprint.com
|
|
Date :
6/21/2009 5:32:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
its like comparing your father and mother.Both have equally strong foundations and can teach you different things about life. At the same time if we look below the surface than their roots are entangled with each other in such an amazing way which gives life to the tree of music above the surface which is ever growing and ever evolving. All forms of music its initial bearings to these two forms of music. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
kitty.abraham07@hotmail.com
|
|
Date :
9/11/2009 12:53:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Dear site owner We are interested to increase traffic to your website, please get back to us in order to discuss the possibility in further detail.Thanks |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
dg23695@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
10/15/2009 9:38:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
The answer is Indian Classical music because it provides us peace in mind. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
abhi.ksrivastava@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
4/23/2009 11:36:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian classical is more powerful as
If i will talk about indian classical there are two parts
1.) Hindustani
2.) Karnatki
lets talk about Hindustani music which have 10 thaut, each thaut have 484 ragas. we can sing it in Dadra which is a cycle of 6 beats, Rupak is a cycle of 7 beats, Jhaptal is a cycle of 10 beats, Ektal is a cycle of 12 beats, Adha-Chautal contains 14 beats, Teen-Tal is comprised of 16 beats.
So there is a vast no.of combinations till now we have not talked about Karnatki.
Wheather in western music its master's base where combinations are limited and that's the reason. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
yrungsung@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
6/20/2009 12:32:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian classical music is more powerful.
The reason:In Indian music, melody and rhythm are more developed and offer a great variety of subtleties, not possible in Western music. Indian notes are divided into small units called shruties (22 microtones in all), whereas Western music has only 12 semitones. The microtones are more subtle then semitones. These microtones adorned with gracetones (gamakas) produce a magical effect. Western music is capable of producing many moods and feelings. While Indian music has generally a principal mood or emotion in a raga. The Indian musician improvises according to his own creative genius within the framework of a raga, but in Western classical music such range of individual improvisation is inconceivable, except in jazz. Moreover, the great use of drums in Indian music emphasises its essential rhythm. It is only by keeping one’s ears and minds open that one can appreciate the special sequences and melodies different from one’s own. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
kartik.bindass@yahoo.in
|
|
Date :
7/13/2009 1:06:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian classical is way difficult then western it beacuse of the reason that in indian classical music we have to look up for lay,taal-rythme,sur,ect. while in western classicals you just have to keep up with rythme knowing the right lyrics...more over indian classical has lots of variety singing when compared with western... |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
skatefliper@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
7/16/2009 11:29:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian form of music is more powerful due to the fact:
If we consider the scales of the western music they are limited ,eg, blues,pentatonic,dorian,etc. But the ragas of the indian classical musical in itself contain a whole bunch of scales for practice and this thing comes in handy for a instrument player. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
adi.comp.engg@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
11/22/2009 12:03:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
What are the charges for the guitar classes |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
sumesh@southalltravel.com
|
|
Date :
11/29/2009 9:26:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian classical is more powerful |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
khanak.mehta@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
12/4/2009 10:50:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
western, as it soothes us better and is true music to everyne's ears |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
mahavir.singh1@genpact.com
|
|
Date :
5/29/2009 6:25:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian form of classical music is more powerful, Indian music itself shown that it has developed within a very complex interaction between different peoples of different races and cultures. Indian music is combination of vocal and instrumental music. In Indian music the melody is based on raag and taal and can be performed on the instruments. Indian music originate from vedic period and later influenced by different culture like arab and English. Indian music is renowned for its varied mood and having diverse element and I believe that if something is origin/parent of new thing it’s a worthless. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
naveensigroha@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
7/18/2009 4:46:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian classical music is more powerful than western coz no one can bring out the magic of music like india does. all great musicians of india can hardly be copied by anyone |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
harishdesh@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
7/29/2009 1:00:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian music is best than western music.
Like Western music, Indian music too is based on melody and rhythm, but it has no foundation of harmony which is so significant in Western music. Indian music is "modal" - based on the relationship between the permanent individual notes known as tonic, with the successive notes. This is the reason why Tanpura (drone) is played in the background of Indian music which reminds one of the tonic notes. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
benz33e@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
7/29/2009 9:03:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Both are exceptionally great, it would not be right to pit one against the other because each have such unique and sometimes unusual tunes that can take you an journeys from meditation to relaxation in minutes to hours . |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
akrita.ag@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
8/13/2009 9:47:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian definately.it is lyrical,inspiring,enchanting,flavoured with great music.besides indian classical music is can be perfected only through many years of practice |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
shanky1035@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
8/17/2009 12:02:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
its really difficult to compare the two forms of music but, i feel that Indian form is much more powerful than the western one because Indian form have lot of variations in their music piece(pitch vice)but yet soothing, which is very hard to interpret sometime on music instrument like guitars.What makes it more powerful is that it is related to the source of origin of flamenco style of guitar yet another distinct and powerful form.and not to mention the different beats and rhythm in the different sales which gives music its life. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
jesse.john@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
5/1/2009 10:27:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Western. Definitely.
Firstly, Western Classical Music (the term 'Classical' is loosely used to include various time periods / forms) evolved a highly sophisticated, but simple and effective system of notating music, namely staff notation. This ensured that the best compositions (and all others that were notated) have been passed on to later generations as the composers originally composed them. Indian Classical Music lacks a comprehensive notation system.
Secondly, Western Classical Music has addressed the issue of harmony explicitly, and very systematically, both in polyphonic and monophonic forms. In contrast, Indian Classical Music only has melodies with a drone accompaniment that remains on the tonic chord irrespective of the harmony implied by the melody.
Lastly, Westerns Classical Music has a strong theoretical foundation for all concepts, which makes education more systematic and widely available/accessible. In contrast, Indian Classical Music is passed on from person to person with no way to asscertain whether what was needed to be passed on was given or not, what more remains to be learnt, the time frame for learning it, whether the student can learn more from another teacher, etc. (Note: In a way, in Western Classical Music, Voice Training appears to be in a similar state, at least for more advanced singers in the West.) |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
fdf@gamiil.com
|
|
Date :
5/30/2009 1:36:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
gssdg |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
guptashashank007@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
9/5/2009 10:24:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
i live in greater noida i m a student of PGDM. i want to perform in my college as a singer. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
gauravsahni_19@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
9/23/2009 4:29:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian classical, to me is more powerful since it has a magnetic effect and by closing your eyes it can take you to its region of origin, which i have not been able to find in westren music. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ashish_986870@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
10/18/2009 5:57:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I think the fusion of the both Form iz Powerful... |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
adnant@live.in
|
|
Date :
5/11/2009 2:42:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian classical music is a much more intense and involving musical experience for the player as well as for the listener, it is a music that takes u a higher level of understanding of highs and lows, pauses and periods of pace and has a greater impact on a listener.. western classical is also nice but it simply doenst have the punch that indian music can add! in other words, i find western classical a bit too mild compared to its indian counterpart. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
nanu.sahay@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
5/31/2009 5:50:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Western music is more powerful.
As we already know and percieve that western music is popular for it's breathtaking screams and thrills.
Indian music is great too.
nothing revitalises ur senses than some indian compositions.
but what makes me bend toward western music is their abilty to awaken to every sense every prospect every personality and every behaviour in a person.
and i believe the one who leaves no voids is the most powerful. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
arjuna.harjai@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
9/2/2009 5:50:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I think western Classical is more popular and powerful ! because these days the interest of the young generation is more inclined towards western classical. PLus Writing on the stave is practiced all over the world. Where as Indian Classical Style of writing music is not followed in countries other than India.
Although Music cant be judged in terms of western or Indian , but the one more in use is the most powerful.
so according to me Western Classical is more powerful. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
sweetysingh@30yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
11/5/2009 4:51:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
i prefer indian music..i think it shows r culture..there is no such music in this whole world which is similar to india music..v indians ve western as well as classical music..bt no such country can peovide the combination of both indian as well as classical... |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
harsh.v.singh@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
11/23/2009 2:10:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
all forms of music are equally powerful!! It depends on who's playing!! And not what he's playing.. music is a vibration of the soul.. you can make rock music sound equally powerful to classical music. It simply fucking depends on YOU!! |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
klotzelron@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
4/12/2009 2:39:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
it's Indian because Indian Classical has powerful Raga's which define its strength.for example akbar's musician tansen use these ragas and because of his powerful ragas he can able to bring rain as well as he can able to lighten up the lamps |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ashwani.1599@rediffmail.com
|
|
Date :
4/15/2009 5:30:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I like western music because they contains more bass in their songs as compared to indian music. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
anku1234_2007@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
12/3/2009 10:35:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian bcz in indian classical music the rhytm varition is concptual.
thats why indian classical music is best |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
nroy54@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
8/14/2009 7:46:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I firmly believe indian music is the best because it is based on classical seven sur's, each one having three types of tunes mild,normal and strong. The combination of sevesn sur's with three types of tunes produces vast variety of every type of melodious music.That's why the varieties covered by indian classical music is very large |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ashwani.1599@rediffmail.com
|
|
Date :
4/15/2009 5:30:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I like western music because they contains more bass in their songs as compared to indian music. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
saumyagarwal@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
4/16/2009 11:16:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Both have their own charm and both are powerful in their own different ways. It's not fair to compare Indian and Western classical forms. Except for th e same seven notes, they're very different. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
ashis_del@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
4/20/2009 3:43:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Both musics are good, but western musicians are best. If we look at the performance of Steve Vai or Marty Friedman, their skills and combination of effects, it is awesome. Western music styles are coming everywhere in Indian music. Of course better instrumentation is always good, but we should try to preserve and enrich our own music. Western classical and Country musics are very good as Indian classical and folk musics. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
mr.mkhullar@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
9/11/2009 11:13:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
indian classical instrument like sitar is a more powerful instrument because all the other string instruments have been derived from it... |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
in.game@rediffmail.com
|
|
Date :
11/29/2009 11:51:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
music is always goog whenther it is western or indian, that's all are our flavours and colors..so enjoy every note, also there is only seven notes in this universe |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
arjuna.harjai@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
12/16/2009 3:59:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Western classical is more powerful because of the concept of harmony , where as in indian classical there is no such thing as harmony .
so ,defiantly western classical has more impact if compared to indian classical |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
bhaveekdesai@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
12/20/2009 11:38:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Of course ,Indian ! The reason being western classical musical notes are based on the english alphabets-c,d,e,f,g,a,b,c#; while Indian musical notes- sa re ga ma originated long back english was spoken...!!! Thus making it more older than english classical & thus more mature & experienced. Music in India has been into picture since the times of Mahabharata & Ramayana... making it the oldest & still surviving classical genre in the world..!!! |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
subrotosen87@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
6/7/2009 3:35:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Western classical music has gradually evolved through the ages. Learn about some of the most notable contributors to western classical music.
When you think of western classical music you immediately think of maestros like Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and Ludwig Van Beethoven. The definition of western classical music however has evolved over time.
The term Western Classical Music focuses primarily on the development of music in the European region. It generally refers to music that has its roots in western art, ecclesiastical (church) music, and concert music.
Music has evolved over the ages, having been influenced by various traditions, developments in technology, etc. Each stage of this evolution has been classified into a certain period. Classical music chiefly evolved within the Classical period. However, to understand western classical music you will also need to know some notable developments prior to and post the Classical period.
Development Prior to the Classical Period
The origins of western classical music can be traced back to the middle ages. Around 500 AD, one of the major influences in music was the Catholic Church. Pope Gregory I is said to have codified the Gregorian chant. Once the chat was documented and standardised it became a base for most tunes of the time. The tunes of the Gregorian chant were monophonic, consisting of a single melody. There was no harmonic support or accompaniment to this.
In the University of Notre Dame, the Organum was created in the ninth century. The organum consisted of two melodic lines sung simultaneously or at intervals. Usually two lead singers would start simultaneously and then would start to sing in intervals gradually increasing the gap between intervals. It was only during the Renaissance period that tunes started to become polyphonic in nature. After the Renaissance, the major development in music was Baroque which was around 1600 to 1750. This highly ornamental style of music was popularised |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
saurav.k@tcs.com
|
|
Date :
8/25/2009 2:39:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I feel that its western music which is more powerful and complete.
When I say complete I mean Indian music is monotonous . You are a ver good singer if you have learnt Indian classical music . Indian music has no concepts of Harmony or if I put it simply no concept of Chords . Chords when played with vocals or leads gives a feeling of completeness . So , I feel western classical music is more powerful as compared to Insian but indian is mighty in itself. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
er_ravinder.singh@yahoo.com
|
|
Date :
12/7/2009 3:33:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
I think that Indian classical music is more powerful because in Indian music the classical ragas can change the surrounding around you as per the Musical notes that is used in them, after listening the ragas you can feel the kind of vibrations around you in your surroundings...
This is what I feel.
Cheers,
Ravinder |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
sushil.tilak@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
10/4/2009 11:56:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian classical music is more powerful than western because
1. music itself originated from India & spread all over the world.
2. Quoting examples of Sufi Form of music...which is such a powerful stream in music which connects the singer & listeners to almighty God.
3. Diverse Folk Music of India...which makes feet dance & gives the feeling of our culture.
4. One can take examples of musicians like Tansen, who had lighted the lamps through the powerful rags like rag Deepak, not only this he was capable of singing Rag Megh Malhar which actually was sung for rains.
5.Musician like Bejubawra showed Lord Vishnu to his guru ravidas through his powerful & divine music.
There are -N- number of examples which proves the strength of Indian Music.
Hence Indian music is more powerful than the western one. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
niki_music@yahoo.co.in
|
|
Date :
11/12/2009 1:41:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
According to me, Western Music is more powerful than Indian Music.
In western Music,
individual brilliance submerges itself in a collective excellence.Each piece of music is written down,with composers defining size of orchestra,tempo of movement..
Contrast to this, Indian music lays emphasis on individuality.There is no concept of essemble,of different instruments playing togeather.Instead, there is soloist alone,with cast of supporting players. The idea of 'harmony', so essential to Western music, is completely unknown here.
Thankyou.
-Nikita Joshi. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
sandeep.verma@pathinfotech.com
|
|
Date :
12/4/2009 2:47:00 PM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Indian Music is more powerful, because it is also used for spritual inner journey. In india almost every god has His own musical instrument. Like Krishna has Flute, Brahma has Veena |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
simon.mazumder@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
12/18/2009 3:32:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
Western Classical Music is more powerful. Because Origin of all present music. Gregorian chant to 21st century contemporay music all are created from western classical form. Rock, blues, Jazz etc all are based on Western classical form. |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|
|
Posted By :
vk.bhatt91@gmail.com
|
|
Date :
12/22/2009 11:07:00 AM
|
|
Answer : |
|
It is very hard to compare both the forms of music. Both are very different and are better than the other in some ways.For example, the fact that Indian classical music uses 22 shrutis against 12 notes in western classical music favors Indian classical music a lot. But at the same time it does not utilizes harmonical structures like its western counterpart. There are highly completed rhythmic structures (taals) in Indian classical music which can not be matched by western classical music (Jazz is not part of western classical music). But then the music notation system of western music is a great tool. So I believe that both are very powerful in their own ways. The best display of this fact is how George Harrison learned Indian classical music from Pt. Ravi Shankar and how Pt. Ravi Shankar felt the need to use western notations to talk about music in his book 'My Music, My Life'... |
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
|